About Nicholson's

We had an outstanding Valentine’s dinner at Nicholson’s Pub in Cincinnati. The food was fantastic (the scotch eggs and lamb were perfect), but what really made the night special was our server, Rudolpho. He took the time to walk me through the scotch selection, explained the differences between the Ardbeg, Lagavulin 16, and Macallan Rare Cask I ordered, and helped me build an amazing tasting flight. His knowledge and enthusiasm made the experience feel like a private whisky lesson. On top of that, the prices were very fair for such high-end pours, which was a pleasant surprise. Great atmosphere, great food, excellent service, and an incredible whisky list. We’ll definitely be back—ask for Rudolpho if you want the best experience! Ambiance is outstanding. Food and drinks are top notch especially the scotch. This is my go to spot in Cincinnati! Kilt is encouraged - 2/14/2026 

Amazing place, and very friendly. A joy to come in and enjoy a meal. Thanks guys!! - 2/14/2026 

Stopped in for brunch. The menu changed, but our food was excellent. Decent service. One of my favorite semi-local, almost not very far restaurants. Great selection of scotches. - 2/11/2026 

Stopped in on 12/8/25 after seeing the Heart concert. Just walking in we were greeted by the bar staff. All the staff my husband and I encountered were friendly, polite and helpful. I don't remember our server's name but she was spot on. She was able to explain the items on the menu in great detail and the difference in the Scotch they offered. The restaurant was clean and decorated to the style of food and alcohol they served. They offer dozens of different types of beer. Neither of us were in the restrooms. The Belhaven Cheese Dip was awesome! It was served with soft pretzels, carrots and celery. I could have eaten it as my dinner. I had the Lamb Loin Chops with Truffle Parmesan Risotto. They were cooked to perfection. I make lamb at home once in a while but mine won't ever taste as good as these. My husband had the shrimp and grits. He ate every bite. He then had their bread pudding for dessert. If you are looking for a place to eat later in the evening Nicholson's Gastropub is a good choice. You don't have to have reservations but if you are going to eat earlier in the evening, you might want to give them a call. - 1/30/2026 

We eat here before every Broadway Show at the Aronoff. We love that they have special food and drinks that go along with each play. It's always good and clever! - 1/21/2026 

Good service, nice to have a waitstaff aware of time limitations to make it to evening broadway show on time and without rushing dinner. - 1/21/2026 

Great food, great service and great price! It was just freeeeeezing inside but I’ll come back in the warmer months. - 1/21/2026 

We love going here before a show. Love the show menu and the variety. - 1/20/2026 

Also a great experience! Good food, excellent service! - 1/20/2026 

Our waitress was great! Go us in and out with plenty of time to make our show at the Aranoff! - 1/19/2026 

First time here and it didn’t disappoint. Wasn’t busy when we came for lunch so it was pretty calm and seated quickly. Ordered the Brussels sprouts as an appetizer and oh my gosh, I was shocked at how delicious they are! Then ordered the chicken & waffles, SO GOOOD! Syrup was so good, the honey butter was amazing. Everything tasted so good, can’t wait to go back - 1/18/2026 

The service was great. Our waitress was very attentive and fast. The food was good. I really enjoyed the fried shrimp and fries. - 1/18/2026 

Due to the show Hamilton waitress was focused on what was coming and not what was already there! - 1/18/2026 

Chani was amazing and the caesar salad and brussel sprouts were awesome! Will be back soon! - 1/18/2026 

We got sat right away by a very nice hostess. Our server was there 2/3 minutes after we were seated to get drink orders and we did food then too. Food didn't take to long and everything was delicious. - 1/16/2026 

Yummy French dip they affectionately call the Welsh dip. Loved the ambiance in here as well. Decor leans into the aristocratic theme I think... Enough TVs that you can see one from everywhere in the restaurant. They aren't huge but will definitely have a game on if you need! - 1/15/2026 

Their British food offerings are excellent. The selection of beer, whiskey and wine is also very good. All the meals were very good. - 1/15/2026 

A great place to dine before a show at the Aronoff. - 1/15/2026 

Nicholson's has great food and great service. Value for the money is excellent. It is noisy when busy, but overall a great choice. - 1/14/2026 

They were very accommodating for our group. As always, the food was perfect, and the service was excellent. We love going there. - 1/14/2026 

This was my first time eating here.. The Food is great I had an outstanding waitress her name is “ Shawna” so when dining in I request her - 1/13/2026 

Recently stopped here before catching Hamilton at the Aronoff center! We made reservations the night before and were able to snag the perfect time to line up with our show. Nicholson's is location directed across the street from the Aronoff and within a short walking distance of Fountain Square and the Contemporary Art Center along with several other fun places making it the perfect spot to grab brunch, lunch or dinner! The atmosphere in the restaurant is incredible and the theming is on par with their menu. Very cozy vibes to go with some hearty comfort food. One thing that drew me to this spot is their themed menu's for broadway shows that are playing at Aronoff. Of course, they had a special Hamilton menu available during our visit, which made for a unique experience. To start we ordered the Belhaven beer cheese served with pretzels, celery and carrots. You can't go wrong with cheese dip and this one didn't disappoint! I went light for my meal and ordered the chicken caesar salad, it was decent. Nothing spectacular, but it did the job. My girlfriend got the traditional breakfast with the banger. She enjoyed her meal and said it hit the spot! A couple other folks at our table ordered the Bonnie Chicken sandwich, which everyone raved about for the rest of the day. Our service was excellent, but it did take a while between ordering, getting our food and the check. The crowd was light when we first arrived, but began to fill up quickly. I recommend making reservations if you're set on dining here to avoid any type of wait. Even if you don't want a full meal, this would still be a great spot to grab a beer or drink. I definitely would like to try more items on their menu and I'm sure we'll make it a tradition to come here before seeing a show at the Aronoff. Check it out if you're in the area! - 1/11/2026 

Recently stopped here before catching Hamilton at the Aronoff center! We made reservations the night before and were able to snag the perfect time to line up with our show. Nicholson’s is location directed across the street from the Aronoff and within a short walking distance of Fountain Square and the Contemporary Art Center along with several other fun places making it the perfect spot to grab brunch, lunch or dinner! The atmosphere in the restaurant is incredible and the theming is on par with their menu. Very cozy vibes to go with some hearty comfort food. One thing that drew me to this spot is their themed menu’s for broadway shows that are playing at Aronoff. Of course, they had a special Hamilton menu available during our visit, which made for a unique experience. To start we ordered the Belhaven beer cheese served with pretzels, celery and carrots. You can’t go wrong with cheese dip and this one didn’t disappoint! I went light for my meal and ordered the chicken caesar salad, it was decent. Nothing spectacular, but it did the job. My girlfriend got the traditional breakfast with the banger. She enjoyed her meal and said it hit the spot! A couple other folks at our table ordered the Bonnie Chicken sandwich, which everyone raved about for the rest of the day. Our service was excellent, but it did take a while between ordering, getting our food and the check. The crowd was light when we first arrived, but began to fill up quickly. I recommend making reservations if you’re set on dining here to avoid any type of wait. Even if you don’t want a full meal, this would still be a great spot to grab a beer or drink. I definitely would like to try more items on their menu and I’m sure we’ll make it a tradition to come here before seeing a show at the Aronoff. Check it out if you’re in the area! - 1/11/2026 

My guest and I enjoyed slaw, fish, jumbo shrimp and chips. Creme burlee for dessert. They had 5 choices of Mocktails. I'll be back. - 1/11/2026 

Before show Dinner Stopped in for dinner before Hamilton! and it was wonderful from start to finish. We started off with a Scotch egg, and I could make a meal out of those alone! Hubby ordered tge Kentucky hot brown, and said it was excellent. I had the bangers and mash with a slice of cornbread. It was delicious. Our server was wonderful, she was attentive, knowledgeable, and didn't hover. - 1/09/2026 

Love the place! The food is fantastic. You definitely want to pick a table ahead of time. I don’t recommend the counter tables. They are extremely small and you have to sit on the edge of the bench seat to eat comfortably if you are a petite person. Otherwise, an amazing restaurant!!!! - 1/09/2026 

Fish & Chips a very good meal on a misty afternoon. A warm calm room and a fire place near. - 1/06/2026 

Wonderful vibe, possibly the best location in Cincinnati that you can get a proper pint of Guinness with great true Irish interior architecture The scotch egg was deliciously salty while also being perfectly cooked with a medium runny core The Caesar salad was acceptable and a great accompaniment after a bengals game To finish it off the brûléed cheesecake with blueberries was perfectly balanced outside of the processed caramel sauce, a great finishing course to a great Cincinnati experience! - 1/05/2026 

Nicholson’s was incredibly accommodating for our large group. We arrived a few minutes early and our table for 15 was set up, complete with two throne chairs on either end. 🙂 We were served in a timely manner even though the restaurant was busy. And we were on time for our show across the street. We all were pleased with our apps and entrees! - 1/05/2026 

A very nice experience before the show. I was not aware of these dinner events. The venue was spacious and accommodating. - 1/05/2026