Starters
- Scotch Egg$7.5pub mustard, arugula
- Spinach & Artichoke Dip$9.5diced tomatoes, pub crisps
- Buffalo Chicken$9.25breaded tenderloin bites tossed in buffalo sauce, stilton blue cheese crumbles, diced celery, creamy dill
- Calamari$11.5steak cut & flash-fried, malt vinegar aioli, house-made catsup
- Belhaven Beer Cheese$9.25crumbled bangers, pub crisps, warm soft pretzels
- Prince Edward Isle Mussels$13.25white wine smoked garlic broth, herb butter, fresh bread
- Duck Fat Fries$8house-made catsup, lemon garlic aioli
- Ploughman’s Bread Board$9.25house-baked bread, olive oil, honey butter, house-made strawberry jam, goat cheese mousse, cornichon pickles
Pub Sliders
two gourmet sliders, served on butter-griddled brioche buns with fries & house-made catsup
- Burger$13all beef patties, pimento cheese, house-made pickles
- Fish$13hand-breaded haddock, shredded romaine, house-made tartar sauce
- Pork Loin$13cinnamon-roasted, red onion, jamaican jerk mayonnaise, shredded romaine
- Tenderloin$15grilled filet medallions, griddled onions, HP aioli, baby arugula
- Impossible™$15plant-based burger patties, HP aioli, shredded romaine
Tavern Fare
- Nicholson’s Fish & Chips13.5hand-breaded haddock, slaw, tartar sauce, house-made catsup, fries
- Shepherd’s Pie$15ground lamb & beef, peas & carrots, mashed potatoes, hearty gravy
- Scot Brown$15turkey, griddled sourdough, bacon, tomato, sharp cheddar, cream sauce
- Buttermilk Fried Chicken$14macaroni & cheese, southern style green beans
- Maker’s Mac & Cheese$11pulled pork, slow-cooked in house, gruyere cheese sauce, scallions
- Bangers & Mash$15caramelized onion gravy, green onions
- Pan-Seared Scottish Salmon$14.5mashed potatoes, grilled asparagus, lemon caper cream sauce
- Pot Roast$14slow-roasted in house, mashed potatoes, southern style green beans
Soups & Salads
- Soup du Jour, Cock-A-Leekie, Tomato Basilcup $4.25 | bowl $5.25
- Wedge Salad$5.5baby iceberg, bacon, pickled onion, granny smith apples, house-made blue cheese dressing
- Tavern House Salad$5.5spring mix, dried cherries, granny smith apples, stilton blue cheese crumbles, house-made bee polled vinaigrette
- Classic Caesar Salad$5.5romaine, shaved parmesan cheese, garlic croutons, house-made caesar dressing
The Royal Couple
Choose two: Soup, Salad, Sandwich or Quiche | $11
- Sandwich:1/2 turnberry club, 1/2 reuben, burger, fish or pork loin slider
- Crustless Quichefarm fresh eggs, diced ham, spinach, mushrooms, gruyere cheese
Specialty Salads
- Pan-Seared Salmon Salad$14faroe island salmon, spring mix, dried cherries, granny smith apples, stilton blue cheese crumbles, house-made bee pollen vinaigrette
- Fried Chicken Salad$12breaded buttermilk chicken tenderloin, romaine & spring mix, hard-cooked egg, bacon, diced tomato, sharp cheddar, house-made honey dijon vinaigrette
- Mediterranean Salad$14.5grilled beef tenderloins, kale salad blend, kalamata olives, roasted red pepper, feta, pepperoncini, house-made balsamic vinaigrette
- Classic Chicken Caesar Salad$12.5grilled chicken breast, shaved parmesan cheese, garlic croutons, house-made caesar dressing
Gastroburgers
- Classic Pub$10.5lettuce, tomato, onion, brioche bun add a topping 1 | blt&egg 3
- Nicholson’s Signature$12.5sweet onion jam, sharp cheddar cheese, arugula, tomato, lemon garlic aioli, ciabatta roll
- Scottish BBQ & Bacon$12.5scottish bbq sauce, sharp white cheddar, bacon, brioche bun
- Shepherd’s$13.75seasoned ground beef & lamb, herbed goat cheese, aioli, arugula, tomato, onion, brioche bun
- Turkey$11.25sharp white cheddar, cranberry-apple chutney, brioche bun
- Impossible™$14.25revolutionary plant-based burger, HP aioli, lettuce, tomato, onion, brioche bun
- Scottish BBQ & Bacon$12.5scottish bbq sauce, sharp white cheddar, bacon, brioche bun
- Nicholson’s Signature$12.5sweet onion jam, sharp cheddar cheese, arugula, tomato, lemon garlic aioli, ciabatta roll
Pub Sandwiches
- Cuban$12pulled pork, ham, house-made pickles, mustard, swiss cheese, ciabatta roll, fries
- Turnberry Club$11turkey, ham, lettuce, tomato, hardboiled egg, lemon garlic aioli, wholemeal bread, fries
- Grilled Cheese & Tomato Basil$11white cheddar, swiss cheese, goat cheese, bowl of soup
- Roasted Pork Sourdough$12jamaican jerk mayonnaise, sharp cheddar, tomato, lettuce, onion, fries
- Caledonian Grilled Chicken$11.5worcestershire marinated chicken, bacon, griddled onion, gruyere cheese, lemon garlic aioli, lettuce, tomato, brioche bun, fries
- Faroe Island Salmon Burger$12wasabi mayonnaise, pickled ginger, green onion, brioche bun, fries
- Turkey Pesto$12gruyere cheese, basil pesto mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato, red onion, griddled sourdough, fries
- Corned Beef Reuben$13sauerkraut, swiss cheese, russian dressing, marble rye hoagy bun, au jus for dipping, fries
Sides
- Side Dish Platter$10.5pick three side dishes, bread
- Roasted Garlic Potatoes$3
- Grilled Asparagus$4
- Local Artisan Bread$2
- Mashed Potatoes$3
- Broccoli$3
- Edamame & Corn Succotash$3
- Macaroni & Gruyere Cheese$4
- Mashed Sweet Potatoes$3
- Southern Style Green Beans$3
- French Fries$3
- Brussels & Sweet Potato Hash$4
Desserts
- Sticky Toffee Pudding$6Scottish steamed pudding, dates, butterscotch sauce, Drambuie whipped cream
- Tipsy Laird$6fried pound cake, fresh sherry-soaked berries, vanilla custard
- English Toffee Cheesecake$7vanilla cheesecake, English toffee bits, chocolate sauce, butterscotch sauce, Drambuie whipped cream
- Apple Crisp$6sweet baked apples, buttery oat crumble, vanilla bean ice cream, pure maple syrup
- Scottish Pot de Creme$7semi-sweet chocolate custard, Glenmorangie scotch whisky, Drambuie whipped cream, candied orange peel
- Butterscotch Pudding$7whipped cream & crumbled English toffee
Happy Hour Features
Monday-Friday | 3:00-6:00pm
WEE BITES | $5
Fried Brussels
Pub Pickles
Bavarian Pretzel Sticks
Crisps & Dip
Smoked Salmon Dip
Candied Bacon